The Story of Puss in Boots and Other Tales (1988, Golden Fairy Tale Collection, Peter Haddock, text by Peter Holeinone, illus. Tony Wolf)
The Story of Puss in Boots and Other Tales, with text by Peter Holeinone and illustrations by Tony Wolf, was published in about 1988 by Peter Haddock Limited as part of their Golden Fairy Tale Collection. The series was originally published in Italian as La Storia Del Gatto Con Gli Stivali e Tante Altre in 1986 by Dami Editore. For more information about the series, including links to my reviews of other books in the series, see Golden Fairy Tale Collection (Peter Haddock Ltd).
Cover, front and back matter
This blue hardcover book spotlighting Puss in Boots appears to be the fourth book of the Golden Fairy Tale Collection.
The covers of all the books have the same golden framing (plants entwined with fairy tale motifs), with a central picture. For this book, the central picture is an illustration that does not appear in the book but encapsulates the energetic mood of the title character Puss in Boots, as he races down a dirt path in his signature boots, the mill of his master's family in the background.
The front and back endpapers are a bright pink. A golden contents page (with the same plant and motif frame as the cover) appears before the copyright page and title page.
Like the other books in this collection, the title page features an elderly cat (wearing a bonnet, shawl, and apron), sitting in a wooden rocking chair and reading the books of the collection to a group of young mice.
Contents (9 stories across 47 pages):
- Puss in Boots
- Til Ulenspighel
- The Peasant, The Snake and the Fox
- The Witch in the Tower
- The Seven Old Samurai
- The Unlucky Warrior
- The Red Dragon
- Dopey Dennis
- The Sleeping Princess
Puss in Boots
- when his master is "glum" about only inheriting a cat, the cat says it is worth more than "a half-ruined mill" and a "mangy donkey"
- we're told the cat's master wasn't surprised when the cat started talking, "for it was quite common for cats to talk in those days"
- the cat pushing its unwilling master into the water was new
- there are a few questions and comments from the queen and princess about the handsomeness of the Marquis
- one line felt slightly out of character for the setting (likely intended for comedy) when the king receives the first gift from the cat and says "Oh ... thanks so much" – compare this with the Queen's more formal response: "This Marquis of Carabas is indeed a very courteous gentleman."
Til Ulenspighel
Ha! He who laughs last laughs longest!
The story of Till riding a donkey with his father while carrying a rude sign is less commonly known. The original stories have been sanitised for children in much the same way other fairy and folktales have been. (In the original circa 1515 chapbook, chapter 2 shows Till baring his bottom to moon the townsfolk from the back of the donkey then sticking his tongue out at them from the front of the donkey while his father rides on, oblivious.)²
The Peasant, The Snake and the Fox
"Why did you do that?" The snake replied, "Because every good deed is rewarded by an evil one, didn't you know that?"
The fox trotted away, sad and disappointed, muttering, "and they say I'm cunning! The cunning one is that peasant. Oh well, that poor snake was probably right, good deeds are repaid with bad deeds," and off he went, his tail between his legs, into the wood.
The Witch in the Tower
The people think if only the bravest samurai of all, Watanabi, was still with them, all would be well. But he is dead and his son, who has his sword, is only a young boy. Nevertheless, Watanabi's son decides to fight the witch. She sees him coming but dismisses him as a threat, only to be blinded by the light of the sword up close, and dispatched by the young boy.
"In his father's memory and in honour of his sword, the boy had freed the city of Kyoto."
The Seven Old Samurai
The Emperor sent for one of the last remaining Samurai, old Raiko...
He asks Raiko to lead an army to wipe out the robbers. Raiko says he is too old to command an army but if he takes six old samurai like himself he can do it. They dress as "humble pilgrims" so the bandits do not think them any threat, but they best them by offering them poisoned sake.
And so, the seven Samurai, too old to wield a sword, served the Emperor for the last time.
The Unlucky Warrior
They are poisoned, but even if they weren't, they would still be enough, because if the Dragon doesn't stop with three arrows in him, I wouldn't have time to fire any more.
So Hido knew that not only had he defeated the Dragon, he had overcome his bad luck.
This story differs greatly from common retellings of "My Lord Bag of Rice", in which a character named Hidesato (Fujiwara no Hidesato, also known as Tawara Toda or Tawara no Tota – Rice-bag Toda) does not appear to be in any way described as unlucky. This version also doesn't feature the gift-giving at the end of the tale, particularly the inexhaustible bag of rice which gives the character his name. Other key differences are that in other versions the dragon is described as a "centipede" and, while Hido fires only three arrows in each story, they are not poisoned, except by his saliva at the end; instead, in one version (Basil Hill Chamberlain's) the centipede itself oozes poison.
The Red Dragon
Told over two pages, this short story is an etiological myth (also known as a "pourquoi" (why) story) explaining how the animals got their different features. It's provenance is uncertain and it may be an original literary tale. I've found several other versions online, but none that provide a convincing source for the tale.⁷
One claims it is an Aboriginal story, but this seems highly unlikely as the animals featured in the various versions are African. If these animals are original to the story then it's far more likely it is a folktale from some part of Africa. Neither Aboriginal nor African tales feature dragons, however, so if this tale is based on real folklore (rather than being a literary creation), the 'dragon' is likely a 'serpent' in the original.
In this telling, a long time ago all the animals (except for the lion, tiger, and butterflies) looked alike. Then one day a red dragon arrived, saying he had seen in the stars that the world was about to come to an end. He offers to carry everyone to a different "planet" that is safer. The lion isn't afraid and says he'll stay but the other animals all fight to get on the dragon's back.
The dragon takes off but the load is heavy and they are scared and don't keep still, so eventually the dragon crashes to the ground. The accident causes the animals to fall off in such a way that they each gain their features (e.g. snake loses legs, rhino bumps head and grows a horn).
There is a single cartoonish illustration of a yellow-brown dragon with tufts of red hair, carrying a crocodile, giraffe (with a butterfly), rhinoceros, elephant, hippopotamus, and hyena.
Dopey Dennis
Once upon a time, there was a little boy called Dennis. Everyone called him Dopey because... well, read on and you will see why.
"You can go home now, lad, you're free!"
And so Dennis went home and lived there happily with his mother. A bit dopey, yes, but he never did anybody any harm, and that's all that counts.
- Vardiello actually swallows what he believes to be poison and climbs into the oven to die, but luckily what he consumed was just a stomach tonic (here the tonic he takes is a group of nuts; in Holeinone's version, the poison he nearly eats is harmless cream)
- it's clearer that the reason Vardiello leaves the cloth with a statue is because he takes too literally his mother's warning "not to do business with people of too many words"
- Vardiello's mother deliberately throws raisins and figs over him as she realises he will blab about the gold and she doesn't want him to be believed
- rather than being sent home free to live happily ever after, Vardiello is sent to a "hospital with the competence to judge such cases" (and it doesn't take too much imagination to realise that that a medieval hospital for the 'insane' would not be a bright future).
The illustrations show Dennis in his many scenes of disaster. He wears a blue coat with a white ruff and a round white hat. His mother appears quite young, in a pink gown and with a white hat with pink ribbon. The final scenes are of Dennis trying to catch the raining figs and sultanas and of him speaking to three magistrates in white wigs.
The Sleeping Princess
This story, told over six pages, is a retelling of "Sleeping Beauty". "Sleeping Beauty" is tale type¹ 410 ("The Sleeping Beauty"). Although the first fully developed literary version is considered the Italian version by Giambattista Basile, elements of the story appear in many earlier tales (including the Völsunga saga). Most modern versions draw from elements of later well-developed versions, namely the French version by Charles Perrault ("The Sleeping Beauty in the Wood"), and the German version by the Brothers Grimm ("Little Brier-Rose").⁹
In this retelling, a queen who has "a beautiful baby daughter" invites "all the fairies in the kingdom to the christening, but unfortunately forgot to invite one of them, who was a bit of a witch as well". There is no big scene of recriminations from that fairy – we're just told that "she came anyway, but as she passed the baby's cradle" she cursed her to die at sixteen by injuring herself with a spindle. The good fairy changes the curse to a sleeping one.
The queen "was always very careful to keep her [daughter] away from spindles". However, on her sixteenth birthday she wandered through the castle and found an old servant spinning. When she asks to see the spindle the old woman hands it to her and "she pricked herself with it."
The queen calls court doctors, wizards, and the good fairy for help. The latter explains that love will break the curse:
"If a man of pure heart were to fall in love with her, that would bring her back to life!"
The queen is "so heart-broken" that she dies a few days later. They lay the princess on her bed and the fairy feels sorry that when she wakens all she will see is strangers so she casts a spell to make everyone in the castle fall asleep. Years go by and a "dense forest" grows around the castle.
A prince from a country close by "[y]oung, handsome and melancholy" but seeks solitude and adventure so decides to explore the forest. He makes it through the woods and rides into the castle. He tries to wake up the people he finds, and "[as] though led by a hand in the complete silence" he finds the princess sleeping.
For a long time he stood gazing at her face, so full of serenity, so peaceful, lovely and pure, and he felt spring to his heart that love he had always been searching for and never found.
He kisses her hand to wake her and she exclaims that she was waiting for him in her dream. Everyone wakes and a few days later the prince and princess marry. The ending draws attention to the unreality of fairy tales:
They lived happily every after, as they always do in fairy tales, not quite so often, however, in real life.
This was a very interesting retelling of "Sleeping Beauty":
- there is no father in the story
- no gifts/virtues are bestowed by the good fairies
- the invitation for the witchy fairy was simply forgotten
- there is no mention of destroying all the spindles in the kingdom
- in many versions of this story the old woman with the spindle is the wicked fairy disguised, but here she is just a servant who runs terrified to tell the queen
- the queen dies of a broken heart (in some versions the parents leave; in others they are part of the sleeping curse and wake with the princess)
- it's specified that the prince must have a pure heart
- there are no thorns, just a dense forest
- there is no mention of other princes trying and failing to reach the castle
- there are no helpful people telling the prince what lies within the forest
- the prince kisses her hand (rather than her lips).
The images by Tony Wolf paint a late medieval/Renaissance setting. In the first image, the baby princess lies in a golden bassinet. Four young fairy women show shock and horror, while one older, wizened fairy holding a wand hunches over the princess, her hands like claws. The young fairies wear cone-shaped hennin with white veils while the older fairy wears a purple escoffion with yellow interior that looks like brains, a long blue veil falling behind her. Her dress looks to be an older style than the younger fairies.
The second image is of a frightened old woman in servant dress reaching out towards the princess, who holds a hand to her head as she faints into sleep.
The third image shows the good fairy, dressed in pink, casting a spell on the people of the castle, who lie sleeping on different steps down a long stairway, guards in armour at the bottom. One of the young women who lies sleeping is reminiscent of Disney's Snow White!
The final images are of the prince, holding his horse's head, and peering through greenery at the castle, kneeling by the side of the sleeping beauty and kissing her hand, then a wedding scene, where the prince and princess stand together in a ballroom, musicians playing in the foreground and nobility dancing in the background. The prince wears a red velvet doublet with trunk hose and the princess wears a Renaissance-style blue gown with an embroidered golden bodice and two embroidered golden vertical bands across the skirts.
Summary
Footnotes
¹ Tale types are a way of classifying fairy tales and folk tales that have the same characteristics. For more information, see Aarne-Thompson-Uther Index (Wikipedia). You can read Giovanni Francesco Straparola's Constantino Fortunato (c. 1550-1553), Giambattista Basile's Cagliosi (1634), and Charles Perrault's Le Maître Chat ou le Chat Botte (1697) translated into English online – see Puss in Boots (D. L. Ashliman).
² You can read an English translation of the original chapbook by Paul Oppenheimer on the Internet Archive/Open Library.
³ You can read a variety of stories of tale type 155 online. See Ingratitude is the World's Reward (D. L. Ashliman). The title of this story in the Italian version of this publication is "La Volpe, Il Serpente e Il Contadino" ("The Fox, the Snake, and the Farmer"). I'm not sure of the exact source for this retelling, as from reading those on D. L. Ashliman's site it seems a combination of the Greek and Scandinavian versions. There may be an Italian source version not translated into English.
⁴ Japanese supernatural beings (yōkai) are of many types. The "oni" are generally translated into English as demons, ogres, trolls, etc. You can read Yei Theodora Ozaki's "Ogre of Rashomon" online – see Japanese Fairy Tales (Project Gutenberg).
⁵ The many versions of “Shuten Dōji” are apparently the most famous monster-conquering stories in the genre of otogi zōshi (a genre of popular Japanese short illustrated prose narratives primarily written during the Muromachi period (1336–1573) and early Edo period). You can read Yei Theodora Ozaki's "The Goblin of Oyeyama" online – see Warrior's of Old Japan and Other Stories (Project Gutenberg). Note there is a popular theory that the Shuten-dōji and his oni followers were historically a group of bandits – see Noriko T. Reider's Japanese Demon Lore: Oni From Ancient Times to the Present, p.19.
⁶ You can read several versions of this tale in English online. For the first translation into English (1887), see Basil Hill Chamberlain's "My Lord Bag o' Rice" (Wikimedia Commons). For Yei Theodora Ozaki's (1903) translation of the tale (based on the retelling by Sazanami Iwaya), see "My Lord Bag of Rice" in Japanese Fairy Tales (Project Gutenberg).
⁷ The Italian story, as published in the Dame Editore collection in 1986, was similarly titled "La leggenda del drago rosso" ("The legend of the red dragon")). Other sources I have found referring to this story include: Understanding Text, Education World, and PlanetOzKids.
⁸ You can read an English translation of "Vardiello" by Nancy L. Canepa online – see Giambattista Basile's The Tale of Tales, or Entertainment for Little Ones (Internet Archive/Open Library). Canepa's translation is the first unabridged English translation taken directly from the original Neapolitan text and considered the most faithful to the original while remaining readable.
⁹ You can read the Perrault, Grimm, and other historical versions online – see Sleeping Beauty (as translated and/or edited by D. L. Ashliman).




